Files
unraid-mcp/unraid_mcp/core/guards.py
Jacob Magar 884319ab11 fix: address 14 PR review comments from coderabbitai/chatgpt-codex
- guards.py: split confirm bypass into explicit check; use .get() for
  dict description to prevent KeyError on missing action keys
- resources.py: use `is not None` for logs stream cache check; add
  on-demand subscribe_once fallback when auto_start is disabled so
  resources return real data instead of a perpetual "connecting" placeholder
- setup.py: always prompt before overwriting credentials even on failed
  probe (transient outage ≠ bad credentials); update elicitation message
- unraid.py: always elicit_reset_confirmation before overwriting creds;
  use asyncio.to_thread() for os.path.realpath() to avoid blocking async
- test_health.py: update test for new always-prompt-on-overwrite behavior;
  add test for declined-reset on failed probe
- test_resources.py: add tests for logs-stream None check, auto_start
  disabled fallback (success and failure), and fallback error recovery
- test-tools.sh: add suite_live() covering cpu/memory/cpu_telemetry/
  notifications_overview/log_tail; include in sequential and parallel runners
- CLAUDE.md: correct unraid_live → live action reference; document that
  setup always prompts before overwriting; note subscribe_once fallback
2026-03-16 03:10:01 -04:00

111 lines
3.6 KiB
Python

"""Destructive action gating via MCP elicitation.
Provides gate_destructive_action() — a single call to guard any destructive
tool action with interactive user confirmation or confirm=True bypass.
"""
from typing import TYPE_CHECKING
from pydantic import BaseModel, Field
if TYPE_CHECKING:
from fastmcp import Context
from ..config.logging import logger
from .exceptions import ToolError
class _ConfirmAction(BaseModel):
confirmed: bool = Field(False, description="Check the box to confirm and proceed")
async def elicit_destructive_confirmation(
ctx: "Context | None", action: str, description: str
) -> bool:
"""Prompt the user to confirm a destructive action via MCP elicitation.
Args:
ctx: The MCP context. If None, returns False immediately.
action: Action name shown in the prompt.
description: Human-readable description of what the action will do.
Returns:
True if the user confirmed, False otherwise.
"""
if ctx is None:
logger.warning(
"Cannot elicit confirmation for '%s': no MCP context available. "
"Re-run with confirm=True to bypass elicitation.",
action,
)
return False
try:
result = await ctx.elicit(
message=(
f"**Confirm destructive action: `{action}`**\n\n"
f"{description}\n\n"
"Are you sure you want to proceed?"
),
response_type=_ConfirmAction,
)
except NotImplementedError:
logger.warning(
"MCP client does not support elicitation for action '%s'. "
"Re-run with confirm=True to bypass.",
action,
)
return False
if result.action != "accept":
logger.info("Destructive action '%s' declined by user (%s).", action, result.action)
return False
confirmed: bool = result.data.confirmed # type: ignore[union-attr]
if not confirmed:
logger.info("Destructive action '%s' not confirmed by user.", action)
return confirmed
async def gate_destructive_action(
ctx: "Context | None",
action: str,
destructive_actions: set[str],
confirm: bool,
description: str | dict[str, str],
) -> None:
"""Gate a destructive action with elicitation or confirm=True bypass.
Does nothing if the action is not in destructive_actions or confirm=True.
Otherwise calls elicit_destructive_confirmation; raises ToolError if the
user declines or elicitation is unavailable.
Args:
ctx: MCP context for elicitation (None skips elicitation).
action: The action being requested.
destructive_actions: Set of action names considered destructive.
confirm: When True, bypasses elicitation and proceeds immediately.
description: Human-readable description of the action's impact.
Pass a str when one description covers all destructive actions.
Pass a dict[action_name, description] when descriptions differ.
"""
if action not in destructive_actions:
return
if confirm:
logger.info("Destructive action '%s' bypassed via confirm=True.", action)
return
if isinstance(description, dict):
desc = description.get(action)
if desc is None:
raise ToolError(f"Missing destructive-action description for '{action}'.")
else:
desc = description
confirmed = await elicit_destructive_confirmation(ctx, action, desc)
if not confirmed:
raise ToolError(
f"Action '{action}' was not confirmed. Re-run with confirm=True to bypass elicitation."
)